Ducati Monster Forum

Local Clubs => OZ monsters => Topic started by: NFG on October 18, 2009, 06:48:58 PM



Title: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: NFG on October 18, 2009, 06:48:58 PM
I've started working on something that seems important to me, but I'm not sure if I'm alone in that.  Basically, the old service manuals are all scanned images, and so cannot be searched or copied, etc.  I started putting the 1994 M900 service manual online:

http://nfgworld.com/ducatiguide/doku.php (http://nfgworld.com/ducatiguide/doku.php)

It's a wiki, which means anyone can correct mistakes or add tips, etc.  Does this seem useful?  Am I recreating a wheel here?  It's time consuming, each page takes 10-30 minutes to type up, but...  If no one's done this already then it seems to be a good idea to me.  I much prefer to read these pages in this format than in the PDF manuals, but I don't want to get too deep into it if someone's already done this or if electronic (non-scanned) versions already exist.

Any thoughts?


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: ducatiz on October 18, 2009, 07:02:21 PM
it's a great make the beast with two backsing idea but seems very work intensive if you are copying the factory workshop manual.

i think what would be cool would be a model-specific wiki for all the various maintenance tasks, but well written and edited by many, wiki style.

but it is a good start..  nice!  [thumbsup]


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: NFG on October 18, 2009, 07:16:40 PM
Well I had kind of figured on two things:

1. Other people might join in, and

2. Some bikes would have similar/identical pages, between years or models.

I'm going to do as much of the 1994 M900 manual as I can stand before my hands fall off or I get bored.  I'm not in a rush and I'm doing it because I'd like it to be done, and I figure others can benefit from my efforts.  if anyone/everyone joins in and starts putting pages together, well hey, a hot new internet resource is born.  =)

Quote
very work intensive if you are copying the factory workshop manual.
Definitely, however I'm better with webpages than I am with bike maintenance, so this is my launchpad.  If people with more experience can add to this starting point, we all benefit.  

UPDATE: As you can see, progress happens quickly enough... (http://nfgworld.com/ducatiguide/doku.php?id=settings:settings_and_adjustments)  It's fun, I type and I learn.  =)


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: ducatiz on October 18, 2009, 07:25:29 PM
i have about 100 lbs of manuals lying around, going back to the 70s.  i've scanned many of them.  i'm debating putting the effort in to scan the 90s supersport manual (93-97, covers the 600, 750 and 900 for all years as well as the 350/400 models in an addenda)...  .. it's like 600 pages, so i have been putting it off...

i have paso 750, sport 750, a few cagivas, all scanned if you're interested in using them...


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: NFG on October 18, 2009, 07:31:37 PM
I can't believe so much of this stuff isn't online electronically already. 

I've got my own server and all the storage in the world...  I'll definitely give your scans a home if you like, but I reckon I'll stick to typing in only the manuals for things I own.  My altruism has limits.  =)

I should really investigate some OCR software... 


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: Justo on October 18, 2009, 08:34:06 PM
Great idea. But what if some noob decides to edit and gets it wrong.

Ive seen some dodgy assed crap added to wikipedia.

ive got the digial version of the M696 if ya want to add it to your library.


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: NFG on October 19, 2009, 01:06:10 AM
Justo: Generally speaking people who know what they are doing will notice and fix errors introduced by newbs.  When someone tells you to use a 13mm fish to blazphaz your shimstock, you can tell it's totally bad advice (use a 15mm, duh) and fix it.

Of course, it's always a risk, but I've run a tech site this way for years and no one's caught fire yet.  =)

I've finished my work on it for today, having completed both the General Operations (http://nfgworld.com/ducatiguide/doku.php?id=generalops:general_operations) and Settings and Adjustments (http://nfgworld.com/ducatiguide/doku.php?id=settings:settings_and_adjustments) segments.


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: loony888 on October 19, 2009, 01:13:47 AM
not too hard to find a free pdf copy online.


http://pdftown.com/Pdf-eBook/Ducati.html (http://pdftown.com/Pdf-eBook/Ducati.html)

cheers,
paul.


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: NFG on October 19, 2009, 01:35:57 AM
not too hard to find a free pdf copy online.

The problem with that is they're not searchable, nor updatable.  It's a bunch of JPGs all in a single file, which is fine if you want the manual, but try copying and pasting a chunk for your buddy or mechanic, or searching for that thing you know you read in it last night and can't find today. 

Plus, they're full of filthy moon languages that terrorist foreigners use.  German, French, Italian...  Disgusting.


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: ducatiz on October 19, 2009, 03:19:28 AM
lus, they're full of filthy moon languages that terrorist foreigners use.  German, French, Italian...  Disgusting.

philistines!  rofl


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: loony888 on October 19, 2009, 12:43:29 PM
The problem with that is they're not searchable




hmm, the index maybe? why would you want to update a manual? if everything is there, it's there.
you can always go through and delete the pages in languages other than english, but it's handy keeping them because the english is written with imperial measurements, the european languages use metric measurements.
stupid i know, it's a metric bike, but they're obviously catering for the yanks.

paul.


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: NFG on October 19, 2009, 12:56:47 PM
Quote
why would you want to update a manual? if everything is there, it's there.
Well, Ducati makes a lot of errors.  Typos and spelling mistakes mostly, but I won't rule out real errors quite yet.   There's also the idea of updating what they say with real photos, real-world advice and extra detail.  A lot of what Ducati put in the manual is a bit terse, I thought.

Typing it all in also means you can google for the info, and you can read a single page without downloading the 40MB PDF, etc.  This is something that would be useful to me, especially if I can get the whole manual..

The problem I have now is that the person who scanned this manual was Italian - he didn't keep any page that didn't have Italian text on it, so the carburetor section (for example) is missing ten pages at a time, and so is basically useless for me (and my current carb problem (http://ducatimonsterforum.org/index.php?topic=30055.msg536406#msg536406)).

...Anyone have a complete 1994 M900 workshop manual?


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: loony888 on October 19, 2009, 05:26:49 PM
ahh, see, now if you do a wiki version in english you may get crazy italians complaining that they can't read it! LOL.
the factory manual remember, is made primarily as a reference for ducati trained mechanics, that's why it's a bit light on detail. maybe a haynes would be better, putting in photo sequences of specific tasks is a good idea, but video, on you tube works well too.
i'm not ragging on you, it's a good idea, just a lot of work and frankly, it's probably out there in one form or another already. try looking for a haynes, i know they do a 900SS one, same carbs. the link i posted is an edited one in italian only huh? bummer, i didn't download it cause i have a 4 valver, sorry bout that.

paul.


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: loony888 on October 19, 2009, 05:29:07 PM
here's some torrents for haynes ones.

http://www.torrentreactor.net/find/haynes-service-manual-ducati-900-ss (http://www.torrentreactor.net/find/haynes-service-manual-ducati-900-ss)

paul.


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: ducatiz on October 19, 2009, 05:35:10 PM

hmm, the index maybe? why would you want to update a manual? if everything is there, it's there.
you can always go through and delete the pages in languages other than english, but it's handy keeping them because the english is written with imperial measurements, the european languages use metric measurements.
stupid i know, it's a metric bike, but they're obviously catering for the yanks.

paul.

hey hey HEY!

yanks know all about the metrics... our cars have been metric since the early 90s and we even know about them meters and kilometers...  !   [drink]


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: loony888 on October 19, 2009, 05:39:16 PM
hey hey HEY!

yanks know all about the metrics... our cars have been metric since the early 90s and we even know about them meters and kilometers...  !   [drink]


yeah but you still measure in imperial don't you? gallons of "gas", miles per hour, ft/lbs etc.
and you drive on the wrong side of the road! still, so do most europeans ;D

paul [thumbsup]


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: ducatiz on October 19, 2009, 05:41:43 PM
Well, Ducati makes a lot of errors.  Typos and spelling mistakes mostly, but I won't rule out real errors quite yet.   There's also the idea of updating what they say with real photos, real-world advice and extra detail.  A lot of what Ducati put in the manual is a bit terse, I thought

not to mention a home mechanic will do things differently than a factory one.  look at the list of tools ducati wants you to buy on the first 2 pages of most of hte manuals.

check out Chris Kelley's howto videos as well, he shows maintenance items from his experience building and racing bikes (ducatitech.com) and they vary substantially from the factory method.


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: NFG on October 19, 2009, 07:04:15 PM
Quote
it's a good idea, just a lot of work and frankly, it's probably out there in one form or another already. try looking for a haynes

Well, I have looked, and I haven't found...  Certainly there are other options (the scanned PDF I have now, buying or pirating a Haynes manual) but critically for me there are no websites.  If, for example, someone on this forum wanted to discuss an oil change, he either re-types the whole thing, types it in his own words, or links to the PDF (or sends the reader to the Haynes site to order the book, or whatever).  There's no option to link to a single page and say "Here's what Ducati says.  Start there, but don't forget to re-primer the zingrod to de-phase the electron flow."

Well, if this project flies, that sort of thing becomes possible.

Quote
i'm not ragging on you,

No worries.  I'm not saying my idea's awesome, and in fact the reason I started the thread was to find out if I was an idiot or if I was re-inventing a wheel...  So far it seems to me the benefits outweigh the cons.  It could be a solid resource, though it'll be a lot of work.  If I'm the only person doing it, the project will begin and end with whatever bikes I own.  If other people contribute, then it just might go somewhere.  =)


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: Justo on October 19, 2009, 07:11:59 PM
Why not just spend your time riding it, not writing about it?  [moto]  [cheeky]  [moto]  [cheeky]


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: ducatiz on October 19, 2009, 07:12:15 PM
i think it's a great idea, perhaps a bit too formal for a wiki though?

it would be nice to be able to better search the tech section here --  a wiki would do that, but it really requires active editing by wiki editors adding tags and tweaking constantly, esp as new stuff is added...

keep thinking about it, you might be on to something....


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: ducatiz on October 19, 2009, 07:15:24 PM

yeah but you still measure in imperial don't you? gallons of "gas", miles per hour, ft/lbs etc.
and you drive on the wrong side of the road! still, so do most europeans ;D

paul [thumbsup]

it's quasi-imperial..  us gallons are smaller than uk gallons, i never understood why..

sure, and we also use avoirdupois for shooting (grains) and such.. converting isn't a problem, but it is usually subject-specific.

i don' think i even own any inch tools. 


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: NFG on October 19, 2009, 07:19:21 PM
Quote
Why not just spend your time riding it, not writing about it?
'cause it's f**king broken and as long as I'm stuck at work, I might as well do something useful instead of picking my nose and gazing out the window.  ;)

Quote
too formal for a wiki though?
The problem is I've got like 20 years of online experience telling me that I can create a neat thing, but can't be counted on to keep it updated myself.  Making something that everyone can contribute to makes more sense to me.  It could even, for example, be integrated with a community site (ie: this forum) so that the same logins work for forum + wiki, allowing people to add all kinds of useful information.  

I love forums, but they suck for structuring the data, and finding info can be tricky.  A structured site would be a good framework for arranging stuff, but requires massive back-end sophistication and/or a rather unreasonably dedicated staff.  A wiki seems like a good middle ground.  Anyone who has a few minutes to spare can construct a guide, a list, a new approach or whatever, and make it part of the available body of knowledge.  

> Like to take a moment to reinforce the fact that I'm not trying to convince anyone my idea is right, but make it clear what my reasons are for thinking it might be cool.  <


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: Justo on October 19, 2009, 07:52:43 PM
'cause it's f**king broken and as long as I'm stuck at work, I might as well do something useful instead of picking my nose and gazing out the window.  ;)


 [clap] [clap]

Noooo way. You can see me?!!!


Title: Re: Putting Workshop Manual online: a good idea?
Post by: monsta on October 20, 2009, 04:37:30 AM
I reckon its sounds like a good idea..
best thing is, your doin a 94 monster first!   [thumbsup]


SimplePortal 2.1.1