Ducati Monster Forum

Moto Board => Accessories & Mods => Topic started by: koko64 on February 12, 2011, 03:15:25 PM



Title: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: koko64 on February 12, 2011, 03:15:25 PM
A year ago I was riding my 900 Monster on the road to Damascus when I had an epiphany. I had a vision and nearly fell off my bike. The vision was not what I expected because He didn't appear, it was bloody Chris Kelly (more akin to El Diablo)!

Chris said, "Why brother are you wasting your time with jet kits, dyno time and generally make the beast with two backsing around with the stock Mikuni carbs when salvation is at hand? You have modified your motor, you are pissed off with carb freezing and frustrated that you cannot get the stock carbs to meet your requirements. Who the hell do you think you are, Doug Lofgren?"

"I would not presume to compare myself to brother Lofgren", I answered, "I just thought I could...". "Silence", he said, "Stock carbs are an abomination upon modified motors, require new needle jets every 5000 miles and give people the shits in cold weather. Buy Keihin FCRs. Oh, and don't be a pussy, get the 41s for a 900 motor", he added.

And then he was gone.

Pondering this I realised I had spent $300-00 on jet kits, $70-00 on needle jets, $200-00 on dyno time and countless hours tuning, researching and test riding. The FCRs are expensive, but they are half the price in the States compared to Oz. If you have a stock bike, don't ride in the cold and don't ask anything too much of your motor, then get a jet kit and accept the limitations, but if you ride all year round, have modified your motor or ride hard there is an answer.



Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: Travman on February 12, 2011, 04:48:05 PM
So have you ordered them?


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: koko64 on February 12, 2011, 05:00:29 PM
They've been on for a year. A recent thread on CV carbs prompted me to start this thread.
I was wondering when I'd get a bite. :D


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: Travman on February 12, 2011, 05:44:47 PM
and... are they everything you've been hoping for?  Is there a noticeable difference when you open the throttle?  [evil]


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: monstermick58 on February 13, 2011, 12:50:06 AM
C'mon KoKo,

Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us, Tell us,









                                      Mmick


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: koko64 on February 13, 2011, 02:29:00 AM
They are absolutely bloody awesome.

Power wheelies from corner to corner through a series of S bends on your favorite mountain road. The wheel comes up on each corner exit and transition through the esses. You know, kinda "ski boating" along.

The throttle response makes the bike feel like it has gained 10hp when peak hp is only a few (2-3) more. It is the acceleration that is drastically different. In short Chris is not overstating his claims about them. They are much easier to tune than the CVs with very little compromise. My friend says his bike (98 M900S) is much more responsive than his former 2000 M900S. Both had the same intake and exhaust mods, open A/B and pipes, one has a tuned FIM ECU, one FCRs. The connection between throttle and rear tyre is immediate and direct.

Another advantage is the tuning logic is linear. This is no surprise as the main jet directly feeds the needle jet and sits beneath it low in the float bowl. It has a feeding effect right through the rev range and can effect as low as 1/4 throttle. The needle moves with the slide as you turn the throttle. There is a circuit to tune each increment of throttle position. The 'fuel draw' is excellent.

I have ridden in zero deg C with no carb freezing. My bike was previously unridable in those conditions. Melbourne has developed incredible humidity to go with it's changable weather.

My fuel economy has improved. I am using less throttle for the same forward motivation. The accelerator pump lets you run an economical midrange cruise setting as it takes care of sudden demands for acceleration.

Looking at my invoice I have actually had the carbs on for twelve months! The year went quick. I can't believe it, so I will edit my original post. It just struck me how long I persisted with modifying the stock carbs on this current bike although I learned a shipload. My wife bought me the carbs when she took pity on me after watching my tuning efforts with the stock carbs over two years. The stock carbs were a weak link in my engine mods and didn't let the porting fulfill it's potential (my opinion). They completed the package and update the intake system short of fitting fuel injection.

I had a Superlight with a modded engine and 39 FCRs but it came with them so I had no back to back comparison. I was spoiled with that bike and so dissappointed with the stock carbs this time around. On this bike I had a back to back comparison and feel I wasted valuable time. I reckon that certain riders should put them on as soon as they buy the bike. For many I feel the open A/B, tuned FCRs and slip on pipes will be the only mod they will ever need for a street bike (well maybe dialed cams and better coils too).

I will soon be dyno testing if they work best with pods or air box with long or short rubber velocity stacks.

There is only one downside besides price; no coke/enrichement system. You squirt the accelerator pump to prime it in cold weather. But you learn a system that works.

Understand that I do not distribute these carbs or sell them. I have no business connection with Chris except for being another customer. I mention Chris in my analogy only in good humour. I don't actually know him except a couple of emails. I usually deal with the charming Candice.

I think that there is more money to be made tuning the schizophrenic stock carbs for an ok but not brilliant result.


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: Nomad on February 13, 2011, 02:44:54 AM
Glad to hear this!  One of my winter mods was putting on the Keihin FCR's.  Bike is still in too many pieces to turn on yet, and awaiting more parts before it is even close to ready, but the new carbs are on!  One thing that made installing them nice was reducing the hoses to the carbs to a  single fuel line, vs I think 5 different hoses on the stock set!


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: koko64 on February 13, 2011, 03:02:04 AM
Yeah, I forgot about that.

Delete ugly vacuum chambers. Less two spring covered vacuum tubes and filters, minus one overflow hose and minus one hose to the left vacuum chamber.

Choke cable, lever and throttle return cable gone.

Clean.


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: ducpainter on February 13, 2011, 05:19:05 AM
Did you get split singles or the banked set?

Pods or stock airbox?


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: greenmonster on February 13, 2011, 08:15:53 AM
Yup, easy to get religious over FCR`s, they are baaad.

But you forgot one thing, koko, the lovely NOISE !!!
At least w pods, the chirping like a bird nest at small openings, a promise what is at your disposal w a simple flick of the wrist.
And, the ROAR of a horny fullgrown bull at WOT!


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: Düb Lüv on February 13, 2011, 08:31:34 AM

But you forgot one thing, koko, the lovely NOISE !!!
At least w pods, the chirping like bird nest at small openings, like a promise what is at your disposal w a simple flick of the wrist.
And, the ROAR of a horny fullgrown bull at WOT!

+1  [thumbsup]


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: Drunken Monkey on February 13, 2011, 09:38:28 AM
Great, now you've reminded me how awesome they were on my 900ss and I'm going to have to go out and get one (yes ONE) for my Duke.

Damn you for forcing me to spend money!



Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: koko64 on February 13, 2011, 12:56:41 PM
Did you get split singles or the banked set?

Pods or stock airbox?

I got the banked set. I investigated getting split singles but I did not want to relocate the frame cross member in the way. You could fabricate medium length inlet manifolds and work around it, but in the end the 4-5 hp increase at the top end may take a similar amount away from the bottom end from some dyno charts I've seen. It appears the greater the capacity/compression, the less loss down low with the short manifolds. I consulted a few people in the States who have used short manifolds and decided to stay with the banked set on my stock bore bike. On a street bike I was happy to keep the torque peak lower, although I am still open to experimenting in the future!

I am running an open air box with K&N filter. I have trimmed the rubber velocity stacks and radiused them so they are flush with the air box and sit back about 20mm further from the filter face. I recently relocated the breather hose to under the left ignitor (over the battery) to more allow room for the throttle cable.

I will soon be testing pods Vs open A/B, long Vs short velocity stacks and breather hose on Vs breather hose off on a dyno.


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: koko64 on February 13, 2011, 01:13:15 PM
Great, now you've reminded me how awesome they were on my 900ss and I'm going to have to go out and get one (yes ONE) for my Duke.

Damn you for forcing me to spend money!



What stock carb does it have?


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: koko64 on February 13, 2011, 01:58:02 PM
dp

I think that you should borrow a set from someone and try them. Then you can decide if they are worth the money.

When you are just taking it easy, say cruising through some mountains with a pillion, you can feel the clean, crisp and smooth carburation. Like a 60's/70's small block V8, fitting a modern carburetor package updates the performance of a great real world motor.
 


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: koko64 on February 13, 2011, 02:01:06 PM
Yup, easy to get religious over FCR`s, they are baaad.

But you forgot one thing, koko, the lovely NOISE !!!
At least w pods, the chirping like a bird nest at small openings, a promise what is at your disposal w a simple flick of the wrist.
And, the ROAR of a horny fullgrown bull at WOT!

Amen to the roar of a horny bull [laugh]


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: ducpainter on February 13, 2011, 02:10:45 PM
I have a policy.

I don't try anything I can't afford...it cuts down on frustration.


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: koko64 on February 13, 2011, 02:26:19 PM
I have a policy.

I don't try anything I can't afford...it cuts down on frustration.

That's a good policy.
Frustrating. Like a girlfriend who's a celibate lingerie model.

I once found a crashed '93 900SS at the yard auctions. It was straight, motor good, etc. It only had fairing damage. It had FCRs on it. I wanted to buy it, take the carbs and adjustable suspension and sell it on at a profit. I couldn't afford it. It went for 2500-00. The motor was worth at least that much from a wrecking yard.

I don't go to the auctions anymore.


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: Drunken Monkey on February 13, 2011, 07:47:50 PM
I have a policy.

I don't try anything I can't afford...it cuts down on frustration.

You give me this advice after I get a ride on a Streetfighter S.

As for the stock carb on a Duke II... I dunno. Some 38mm CV thingamabob.


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: Howley on February 14, 2011, 02:32:28 AM
One day when i'm rich I'll buy FCR's, I've been lusting after them for soooo long.


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: 671M900 on February 14, 2011, 06:29:52 AM
You give me this advice after I get a ride on a Streetfighter S.

As for the stock carb on a Duke II... I dunno. Some 38mm CV thingamabob.

Oh yes... I'm in the same boat, damn Streetfighter...

I have FCR's on the 900, never had the Mikuni's on it. The FCR's are perfect, and the bike has a great character to it. I thought that's how monsters were supposed to be until I rode a stock 900ss with mikunis. I realize they are different frames and bikes, but powerwise, the FCR's are more fun, it's like a big ol' dirtbike.


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: showerfan on November 22, 2012, 07:02:13 PM
KOKO! did you ever try the pods? verdict?


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: koko64 on November 22, 2012, 08:45:36 PM
Yeah I did.
Pods(ru1750) > too loud and least performance when tested on FCRs when tested against various airbox permutations. Great weight loss, easy servicing and possible extra airflow to rear cylinder.
See "pods Vs open airbox" on search.


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: carbmon on November 23, 2012, 12:39:39 PM
Cool resurrected thread, loved reading your epiphany, Koko.

FCR’s are the bomb when it comes to motorcycle carbs.

IMHO, all who own them should read and re-read this great guide by Patrick Burns (http://www.factorypro.com/tech/tech_tuning_procedures/tuning_FCR_Burns,Pat.html) which helps demystify them greatly.


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: showerfan on November 23, 2012, 01:15:53 PM
yeah, +1 -- the prose from the Aussie was moving. and hillarious [laugh]


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: koko64 on November 24, 2012, 04:09:12 PM
Cool resurrected thread, loved reading your epiphany, Koko.

FCR’s are the bomb when it comes to motorcycle carbs.

IMHO, all who own them should read and re-read this great guide by Patrick Burns (http://www.factorypro.com/tech/tech_tuning_procedures/tuning_FCR_Burns,Pat.html) which helps demystify them greatly.

Burns' tuning guide is something I regularly consult.  I've even bothered him a few times from over here. He has been generous with his knowledge for sure. He should write a book, I'd buy it.


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: koko64 on November 27, 2012, 04:07:57 AM
I have a policy.

I don't try anything I can't afford...it cuts down on frustration.

DP got some FCR41s.
Nate, how did you find them?

EDIT:
He has them on his winter jobs list.


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: koko64 on December 06, 2012, 09:52:30 PM
KOKO! did you ever try the pods? verdict?

Showerfan
I honestly would consider extending the airbox on a 900 and running shortened, "ported" velocity stacks. See the thread for this, "Enlarged Airbox and other Airbox mods". The most benefit would probably be with porting, big carbs and higher comp. I did not test these mods on a stock 900 motor. I hope to sometime, but I don't work on many Ducatis. I don't know if it is worth doing if your bike has W heads.
I must be getting old, but I found the pods too loud and brash sounding. It really annoyed the shit out of me. The clincher for me was the slightly reduced performance. Every hp is precious when you have so few [laugh].


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: showerfan on December 09, 2012, 07:10:17 PM
will definitely take that into consideration, though i'm not sure i know enough about this to do it myself. i have ordered the ``flat slides'' as my mechanic says. i am SO STOKED for a touch more drive-ability on this old bike -- it sometimes likes to JUMP when i crank the throttle, sometimes not so much...


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: PhilB on December 09, 2012, 07:56:30 PM
I'm interested in the comments about cold weather.  My original carbs wore out a couple years ago, so I had the choice.  I was worried about the lack of an enrichener, and stories that bikes with the FCRs can be harder to start, especially in cold weather, so I got a used set of the OEM carbs.  They seem to do alright in the cold, once I beefed up the starter system.

Are the FCRs actually good in cold weather?

PhilB


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: koko64 on December 10, 2012, 02:26:06 AM
With no enrichener, you learn to use the accelerator pump to squirt fuel into the manifolds and hold the throttle at just off idle/fast idle. A richer Idle mixture setting in winter helps. So more involved to start, but runs better in the cold with no freezing and great performance.


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: PhilB on December 10, 2012, 09:55:10 AM
With no enrichener, you learn to use the accelerator pump to squirt fuel into the manifolds and hold the throttle at just off idle/fast idle. A richer Idle mixture setting in winter helps. So more involved to start, but runs better in the cold with no freezing and great performance.
Thanks.  I might well look into that next time I need carbs.

PhilB


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: showerfan on December 10, 2012, 07:44:44 PM
phil -- how did you `beef up the starter system?'


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: PhilB on December 11, 2012, 01:25:46 PM
phil -- how did you `beef up the starter system?'
Mainly by upgrading the wires from the battery to the relay, and from the relay to the starter, from 6ga to 4ga, and adding a dedicated ground line back from the starter to the battery instead of relying on grounding through the frame/engine.  I also was able to get a stronger battery that was the same physical size as the original.

PhilB


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: Autostrada Pilot on December 20, 2012, 01:37:31 PM
+1 on a wiring upgrade for the starter.  Made a HUGE difference in how fast the 900 carbies start.  I ordered the Powerlet kit for like $30.


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: dlearl476 on January 11, 2013, 09:09:16 AM
I'm interested in the comments about cold weather.  My original carbs wore out a couple years ago, so I had the choice.  I was worried about the lack of an enrichener, and stories that bikes with the FCRs can be harder to start, especially in cold weather, so I got a used set of the OEM carbs.  They seem to do alright in the cold, once I beefed up the starter system.

Are the FCRs actually good in cold weather?

PhilB

Phil, if one of those stories was mine, I apologize. My cold wether starting issues were completely self-induced. I installed the Powerlet kit and had my carbs adjusted and it helped a bit but not much. Couldn't get the bike started to go on a New Year's Day ride.
I was working on that and changing the belts the other day and the friend who was helping me/showing me how to do it noticed that the battery I had was way underpowered.

See, when my OEM batt died a couple of years ago, I didn't want to replace it with a wet cell and the Westco dealer sold me what he said was listed for our bikes. Well, it was a 9Mah/120CCA batt when spec calls for a 10Mah/150 CCA BATT. (IIRC)

So installed a TrueGel gel hybrid battery yesterday (16Mah/190CCA) and it fired right up the second I hit the starter button on a 35 degree day. Don't know whether to jump for joy or kick myself in the ass.

Otherwise, ditto to all the praised heaped on the FCRs. I like them so much I want to get a pair for my F650.


Title: Re: Keihin FCRs Vs Mikuni CV carbs
Post by: PhilB on January 13, 2013, 08:41:52 AM
Phil, if one of those stories was mine, I apologize. My cold wether starting issues were completely self-induced. I installed the Powerlet kit and had my carbs adjusted and it helped a bit but not much. Couldn't get the bike started to go on a New Year's Day ride.
I was working on that and changing the belts the other day and the friend who was helping me/showing me how to do it noticed that the battery I had was way underpowered.

See, when my OEM batt died a couple of years ago, I didn't want to replace it with a wet cell and the Westco dealer sold me what he said was listed for our bikes. Well, it was a 9Mah/120CCA batt when spec calls for a 10Mah/150 CCA BATT. (IIRC)

So installed a TrueGel gel hybrid battery yesterday (16Mah/190CCA) and it fired right up the second I hit the starter button on a 35 degree day. Don't know whether to jump for joy or kick myself in the ass.

Otherwise, ditto to all the praised heaped on the FCRs. I like them so much I want to get a pair for my F650.
Alright.  Well, the carbs I have on there now only have about 50K on them, so maybe 10 years or so down the road when they wear out, I'll give the FCRs another look.

PhilB


SimplePortal 2.1.1