Title: High compression pistons Post by: pcv57 on February 25, 2011, 02:27:05 PM I was thinking about buying 11:1 high compression "drop-in" pistons for my s2r1k. The write up said it would be a 7hp gain for the 1000DS motor. I'm wondering if this is true and what the downside is. Anybody do this mod?
Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: scduc on February 25, 2011, 02:40:22 PM I also pondered this, but after talking to my tech, I'm convinced that this is not a really the way to go. If you do the math, it comes out close to $100 per 1hp and you'd be way better off going with the big bore kit. With cutting your sleeves, re-coating and new gaskets along with the pistons, you will end up spending an extra $350 or so, but you will gain much more all around. torque and high end.
Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: pcv57 on February 26, 2011, 04:45:08 AM What did your mechanic quote you for doing the big bore kit? I've been quoted $1700 to do the job.
Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: scduc on February 26, 2011, 09:41:05 AM If I do the tear down and reassemble, around $450 for the pistons, another $450 for boreing and coating the sleeves then around $150(he could not quote me, but this is the extreme) for the gaskets. He said he would fit the rings and pre-assemble. I would remount the sleeves and do the mechanical work. Take the bike back to him and he would do the fine tuning for another $100. My guess is that it will be much less then $1500. I do plan on doing this, just not sure how soon.
Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: He Man on February 26, 2011, 10:37:54 AM i think the gaskets are actually over $100 each last i checked. They are freaking EXPENSIVE.
if your going to strip your bike apart, why not just do the bigbore too? How many miles does ur bike have? Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: ducpainter on February 26, 2011, 11:45:41 AM i think the gaskets are actually over $100 each last i checked. They are freaking EXPENSIVE. Commoto lists those gaskets at 47.89.if your going to strip your bike apart, why not just do the bigbore too? How many miles does ur bike have? You might be thinking SBK. Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: ducatiz on February 26, 2011, 01:11:28 PM yeah, once you have the heads, jugs and pistons off it's time to pull the rods and balance them.
well, once you do that, just split the case and get the crank lightened and balanced. it's not that much extra. Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: scduc on February 26, 2011, 02:38:32 PM Its just like every thing. You have to draw a line somewhere. For most of us modding the top half is really not a big deal. However if you start getting into the lower, then mo money and time get involved. Every one has different goals and destinations. Doing alittle at a time gives me the financial benefit and also gives me something to do during the winter. If I were to do it all at once, then I would be finished and half the fun would be gone. Either way, the original post is going to have to pull the sleeves and spending the extra money to bore and recoat will be (IMHO) money well spent.
Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: Drunken Monkey on February 26, 2011, 08:09:29 PM HP, while nice for racing, is not the only thing. There's this other thing called "torque"...
Look at the claimed increases for the torque curve on your bike (preferably an actual dyno chart) before you leap in with both feet. My high-comp + etc job ran about 1500 and it was well worth it for the massive midrange increase far more than the extra 5 HP peak output. As always, YMMV. But see if you can't find a before and after dyno chart for this particular mod... Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: Buckethead on February 26, 2011, 08:16:11 PM There's this other thing called "torque"... I'm thinking that for a grand and change, you could probably swap in an 1100 motor with a reflashed ECU to make it work. Dunno, tho. Haven't really priced crashed HM's/MS1100's/Monster 1100 motors. Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: ducpainter on February 27, 2011, 05:54:50 AM I'm thinking that for a grand and change, you could probably swap in an 1100 motor with a reflashed ECU to make it work. I think you're low.Dunno, tho. Haven't really priced crashed HM's/MS1100's/Monster 1100 motors. Most of the gains from a big bore kit actually come from the compression increase normally associated with the new pistons so drop ins make sense. We're not talking about a 750 motor here...no need for a motor swap IMO. Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: pcv57 on February 27, 2011, 06:10:30 AM The interesting thing was that their website stated the high comp pistons would give me 7hp gain and the big bore kit 8% more hp. At 85hp, 8% would give me 6.8hp. Hmmm, not the best sales technique.
I talked to Steve at ECS in NY and he thinks I should invest in the TPO Beast R and a PC III instead. Since they don't make a PC for that bike, it would be one for an M1000 and a custom map. It would still cost around a grand just to do that! ??? Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: ducpainter on February 27, 2011, 06:33:22 AM Steve knows his stuff.
Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: He Man on February 27, 2011, 07:29:37 AM You are right dp about the gaskets.
Steve showed me a few of the Hi comp bigbore kits for the DS1000. My bike had 82hp/68tq on their rented dyno. On that same dyno, fully kitted DS1000 were making about 95hp/80tq. I may be off on the torque number though. I think they quoted a little lower than $2500 to do the whole thing with the bike in house. Parts and labor, PCIII + Custom map. One day, when the bike actually needs it... Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: kopfjÀger on February 27, 2011, 09:04:53 PM Go for the 1123 Pistal kit. [evil]
http://www.ducshop.com/product_view.php?cat=6&pid=303 (http://www.ducshop.com/product_view.php?cat=6&pid=303) Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: pcv57 on February 28, 2011, 07:41:07 AM Ferracci quoted me $3k to install the 1100 big bore kit, Ferracci programmable ECU w/ 2 switchable maps using flash-to-pass button, and set up on dyno. Again, I'm not sure if pumping another $3 grand into this bike is worth it or do I look for something else. I do love my S2R, but it is what it is.
Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: atomic410 on February 28, 2011, 09:42:53 AM FWIW I was gonna put a 2mil kit in my 620 but desided that lightweight wheels would provide me with the same/similar effect that i was looking for for less $ and also greatly improve the handeling [bacon]
Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: He Man on February 28, 2011, 11:54:11 AM Ferracci quoted me $3k to install the 1100 big bore kit, Ferracci programmable ECU w/ 2 switchable maps using flash-to-pass button, and set up on dyno. Again, I'm not sure if pumping another $3 grand into this bike is worth it or do I look for something else. I do love my S2R, but it is what it is. Really depends on what you look for in a bike. For myself, I'd advise against it because my bikes main use is that of a robo-mule. the 85hp motor is plenty fun for the twistys, it lakcs at the track, but the bike itself sucks as a track rat anyway. So unless your bike actually needs engine work due to mileage or what have you, id wait till its necessary. Unless you have the money to spare, then hey you could spend it on hookers and coke if you wanted to. It wouldnt make a difference in the end cause its extra cash for you and no one has the right to tell you how to spend it. but i think 3k is a good price i think. Ferrachi from what I HEAR, do great work, but are not so customer friendly when it comes to regualr purchases. I got quoted $2500ish for everything except the 2 map thingy. just a Power commander + custom map by Steve at ECS. Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: pcv57 on February 28, 2011, 01:04:21 PM It appears that a few of us use ECS. I'd be interested if anyone plans to attend his next Open House. I spoke to him the other day and he told me he has a new mechanic that will be starting shortly.
Anyway, hookers and coke vs. bike mods is a tough decision. You will have something to show for both afterwards, but one I could explain to the wife, the other not so much. I take that back I couldn't explain either one. Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: atomic410 on February 28, 2011, 01:25:44 PM WWCSD what would Charlie Sheene do? [bacon]
Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: Buckethead on February 28, 2011, 02:26:47 PM WWCSD what would Charlie Sheene do? [bacon] Hookers and blow. Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: atomic410 on March 01, 2011, 06:34:05 AM 2 porn stars and blow [bacon]
Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: He Man on March 01, 2011, 06:38:58 AM destroy a hotel room with 2 hooers while on blow
Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: ducatiz on March 01, 2011, 07:01:17 AM destroy a hotel room with 2 hoosiers while on blow fixed for humor Title: Re: High compression pistons Post by: atomic410 on March 01, 2011, 10:04:11 AM fixed for humor I wouldn't be suprised if he wasn't alowed into canada anymore [bacon] |