Ducati Monster Forum

Moto Board => General Monster Forum => Topic started by: Rxmfn7 on August 04, 2011, 10:36:15 AM



Title: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: Rxmfn7 on August 04, 2011, 10:36:15 AM
So, past few times Ive been riding the bike, I heard what I had thought was an excess of chain/driveline noise. MY chain also appeared (just from looking) to be pretty loose to me. So today I head out to the garage just to check it out and see if I can find anything myself before taking it to the dealer. Upon looking at the rear 2 pinch bolts, I notice they are completely loose. Like, spin them easily with your finger loose. I took a picture from straight on, you can clearly see the bolts are not even close to seated. So from when I had my 600mile service done, to now (~1600miles), Ive been riding around with my rear wheel pretty much doing whatever it wants. My sprocket doesnt look noticeably chewed up, but would anything else possibly been damaged by this?

(http://a2.sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc6/285505_266671123347566_100000140415415_1215756_4896993_n.jpg)


Title: Re: Riding arpound for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: avizpls on August 04, 2011, 10:41:09 AM
the eccentric's surfaces. When you break it twists one way, on the gas torques it the other way. Back and forth it could have caused some issues.

 [thumbsdown] dealers.


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: rockaduc on August 04, 2011, 12:49:11 PM
YIKES!!!!!  You better pull it apart and inspect thoroughly.


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: Punx Clever on August 04, 2011, 06:50:11 PM
So, past few times Ive been riding the bike, I heard what I had thought was an excess of chain/driveline noise. MY chain also appeared (just from looking) to be pretty loose to me. So today I head out to the garage just to check it out and see if I can find anything myself before taking it to the dealer. Upon looking at the rear 2 pinch bolts, I notice they are completely loose. Like, spin them easily with your finger loose. I took a picture from straight on, you can clearly see the bolts are not even close to seated. So from when I had my 600mile service done, to now (~1600miles), Ive been riding around with my rear wheel pretty much doing whatever it wants. My sprocket doesnt look noticeably chewed up, but would anything else possibly been damaged by this?

So... you decided not to adjust the chain because...?  I mean, you must have at least lubed the chain (which would imply checking it's tension and a quick glance over the swingarm) in that 1000 mile interval... right?  Thats like saying, "My tire sure does look flat... oh well, I'll ride it anyways."


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: xcaptainxbloodx on August 04, 2011, 07:05:48 PM
I dont think you could go 1000 miles with pinch bolts that loose, i went on a test ride on a bike with pinch bolts that loose and got all of 30 feet before it became unridable.

maybe vibration loosend them, maybe someone tried to adjust the chain and forgot... no clue how but a SSS cannot ride very far with loose pinch bolts.


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: Rxmfn7 on August 04, 2011, 07:17:23 PM
Because I bought a brand new bike and had it dealer serviced so I didnt have to worry. It has "appeared" that loose to me since I picked it up, but didnt question it because it was just serviced, and I didnt notice any problems until recently. I had assumed the dealer tech who gets paid to do this for a living, serviced my bike correctly.

So... you decided not to adjust the chain because...?  I mean, you must have at least lubed the chain (which would imply checking it's tension and a quick glance over the swingarm) in that 1000 mile interval... right?  Thats like saying, "My tire sure does look flat... oh well, I'll ride it anyways."


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: rockaduc on August 05, 2011, 02:50:16 AM
In 1000 miles i probably clean and lube my chain at least 2 x's.  that usually includes inspecting the entire driveline for any shenanigans.

Just trying to say you should establish regular maintenance schedule for your bike.  It will help to avoid issues like this.


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: WhiteStripe on August 05, 2011, 05:58:01 AM
I mean to lube my chain every 600 miles, I actually lube my chain much less.


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: xcaptainxbloodx on August 05, 2011, 06:48:45 AM
That slipped by me. but yeah, I clean and lube my chain every 300-500 miles. Regular maintenance saves you money and can save your life.


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: JimmyTheDriver on August 05, 2011, 07:25:27 AM
When I was adjusting my chain and forgot to tighten the pinch bolts, my chain came completely off within 10 feet of my garage.  I can't see how you would have been able to ride 1000 miles.  Granted I am no expert, but I would assume they started to come loose over the past few hundred miles which is why you felt the chain slack. 

-Jimmy


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: Rxmfn7 on August 05, 2011, 07:27:54 AM
I was planning on chain lube every 1000 miles, being I dont ride in rain or very dirty conditions. Ive found too much lube just makes a mess. But thats not my point,.. the bolts should not have come loose from normal riding vibrations, so they were either not torqued properly or never tightened. Sure, maybe if I was a bit more anal I wouldnt caught it earlier, but I shouldnt have to double-check dealer maintenance.


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: Punx Clever on August 05, 2011, 02:26:38 PM
So, tips for a new bike owner:

Lube every 300-600 miles.  Chain wax leaves less mess than other types of lube.  It will keep your chain happy, which keeps you happy.  The chain that came on my s2r lasted 20k miles.

Before you ride (among other things): Check the chain's tension against the owners manual.  It will stretch and loosen.  Part of owning a chain.  Also catches other things that can come up before they are a problem...

Finally: If something is wrong, it's wrong. Never assume that it's right just because someone else was supposed to check it. 


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: speedknot on August 05, 2011, 05:27:16 PM
Finally: If something is wrong, it's wrong. Never assume that it's right just because someone else was supposed to check it. 

I can see what Rxmfn7 means about trusting the trained mechanic to "do the right thing".  I think we've all been guilty of it at one time or another.  However, when it comes to only two wheels on the road, i dont trust anyone but my self to make sure my bike is roadworthy.  Just for piece of mind, I have to check and double check any work that was done by myself or a mechanic.


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: Punx Clever on August 05, 2011, 06:15:52 PM
I can see what Rxmfn7 means about trusting the trained mechanic to "do the right thing".  I think we've all been guilty of it at one time or another.  However, when it comes to only two wheels on the road, i dont trust anyone but my self to make sure my bike is roadworthy.  Just for piece of mind, I have to check and double check any work that was done by myself or a mechanic.

I do too.  And in the case of a car... I'd agree.  I'm not trying to be an ass, just giving good advice.


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: xcaptainxbloodx on August 05, 2011, 07:31:01 PM
I was planning on chain lube every 1000 miles, being I dont ride in rain or very dirty conditions. Ive found too much lube just makes a mess. But thats not my point,.. the bolts should not have come loose from normal riding vibrations, so they were either not torqued properly or never tightened. Sure, maybe if I was a bit more anal I wouldnt caught it earlier, but I shouldnt have to double-check dealer maintenance.

alot of things can happen to a motorcycle in 1000 miles. servicing the chain about every 300 miles is not only the proper way to care for a chain, but a very easy way to check various things  (like pinch bolts).

  It is unfair to blame a mechanic for something like this happening 1000 miles after he touched it, and there is NO WAY (as in mechanically impossible) that the bike left the shop in that condition.  had you serviced your chain at a more reasonable interval you may have found the pinch bolts out of torque spec. (which is scary but not uncommon as a machine gets broken in.)


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: Duc796canada on August 06, 2011, 03:00:13 PM
Ouch, that is scary! I have been over servicing my chain then, I have own dirt bikes and we lube the chains every ride, so i have been doing my monster's chain every second or third ride regardless of mileage, I will cut back :) On another note, people should " pre-flight" their bikes we do it before going flying, the onus is on you that is getting on the motorcycle and or aircraft, the mechanic or technician is not going to be with you when a mishap happens that could have been prevented with a simple "pre- flighting/walk around" on your machine. To make mistakes is to be human, technicians are human.  [Dolph]


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: corey on August 09, 2011, 08:04:07 AM
i dont know guys... these bolts are supposed to be greased, and torqued to 33nm (~25 ft.lb.) in a 1-2-1 sequence. that's a pretty tight bolt.
i've ridden my S2R for AT LEAST 1500 miles without adjusting the chain (it was lubed more frequently), and never in a million years would I even THINK that these bolts could come loose. Had to be improper re-installation in my opinion. they weren't torqued properly, and damage was done.

As a mechanic working on something that is responsible for somebody's LIFE, you don't just ASSUME that this guy is going to check his chain in 300 miles. you torque that shit down right, and then you check it again, and then you check it one more time before it leaves the shop.

is the mechanic responsible? think whatever you want.
Could the RIDER have caught this issue earlier if he checked his chain more often? Yea, obviously.
is the RIDER'S FAULT these bolts came loose because he didn't check his chain stretch every 10 miles? no way in hell (IMO)


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: Punx Clever on August 09, 2011, 09:34:10 AM
i dont know guys... these bolts are supposed to be greased, and torqued to 33nm (~25 ft.lb.) in a 1-2-1 sequence. that's a pretty tight bolt.
i've ridden my S2R for AT LEAST 1500 miles without adjusting the chain (it was lubed more frequently), and never in a million years would I even THINK that these bolts could come loose. Had to be improper re-installation in my opinion. they weren't torqued properly, and damage was done.

As a mechanic working on something that is responsible for somebody's LIFE, you don't just ASSUME that this guy is going to check his chain in 300 miles. you torque that shit down right, and then you check it again, and then you check it one more time before it leaves the shop.

is the mechanic responsible? think whatever you want.
Could the RIDER have caught this issue earlier if he checked his chain more often? Yea, obviously.
is the RIDER'S FAULT these bolts came loose because he didn't check his chain stretch every 10 miles? no way in hell (IMO)

OP noticed his chain looked loose, but did not take action.  It's not that he didn't check often enough, but that he ignored a problem.

If the story was "About 300-600 miles ago I had my bike serviced.  When I went to oil the chain, I noticed it was a little loose.  Upon further inspection, the eccentric's pinch bolts were loose.  Should I be mad at the mechanic?"  Then yes, mechanic's fault entirely.


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: corey on August 09, 2011, 09:35:57 AM
we're saying the same thing here.
OP shouldnt have ignored the loose chain, that's fair. but it was someone else's ignorance that caused the problem to begin with.


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: Rxmfn7 on August 10, 2011, 05:59:11 AM
I didnt post the thread just to complain or point blame. Just wanted to address the issue and ask for options of anything else that could have been damaged. Other posters turned it into "You shouldve caught it sooner". Fair enough.. but I didnt.. oh well lets move on. Still, in my opinion there is no way those bolts could have just rattled loose, and just because I didnt check it a bit sooner, doesnt change the fact that a dealer tech didnt tighten the bolts. But whatever..


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: rockaduc on August 10, 2011, 08:11:00 AM
I didnt post the thread just to complain or point blame. Just wanted to address the issue and ask for options of anything else that could have been damaged. Other posters turned it into "You shouldve caught it sooner". Fair enough.. but I didnt.. oh well lets move on. Still, in my opinion there is no way those bolts could have just rattled loose, and just because I didnt check it a bit sooner, doesnt change the fact that a dealer tech didnt tighten the bolts. But whatever..

Have you pulled it apart to check for damage yet?


Title: Re: Riding around for ~1000 miles with loose pinch bolts
Post by: corey on August 10, 2011, 01:11:43 PM
i'm literally amazed by the fact that you WERE able to ride with them loose...

as stated, the eccentric hub was likely twisting to a certain degree in each direction, but it would really only be on stop/start and hard accel/decel...
see any metal shavings in/around the hub area?

there's a guide for removing the eccentric hub in the tutorials section.
http://www.ducatimonsterforum.org/index.php?topic=34425.0 (http://www.ducatimonsterforum.org/index.php?topic=34425.0)

i would certainly pull it out and have a look.
best case, it's fine and you did some work but at least you know...
worst case, it's all ground up and you need a new one.

If you DO need a new hub, at that point what I (emphasis on I) would do is contact the dealer and start talking about compensation for replacing the hub. The hubs pop up on ebay, the classifieds here, and www.gotham-cycles.com (http://) occasionally in the $150 - $300 range.


SimplePortal 2.1.1