Title: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: asherrick on August 29, 2013, 07:58:33 PM I have a M1100s and am looking for a more aggressive riding position. I had a 1198s and don't want to go that aggressive with it but somewhere in between. I'm thinking that clipons, like Speedymoto Tall Boys, or the Suburban Machinery bars might fit the bill. Has anyone ever compared the two?
Any other thoughts? Thanks! Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: ungeheuer on August 29, 2013, 09:04:14 PM No FHE with Suburban Machinery bars (I do like the look of those though), but I have run Speedymoto Tallboys and subsequently swapped those out for Swatt clipons with 3 1/2" rise. Swatts are no longer in production, but Woodcraft makes something which does the identical job as my Swatts.... and the Woodcrafts also look nicer too IMO.
Although I found Speedymoto Tallboys more appealing to the eye that the Swatts I ultimately ended up with, I wasnt happy with the lack of sweep-back offered by the Tallboys. Here's my experiences if you're interested.... http://www.ducatimonsterforum.org/index.php?topic=21407.0 (http://www.ducatimonsterforum.org/index.php?topic=21407.0) ....for the purposes of comparing you can pencil in Woodcraft in place of Swatts... One thing to consider is the cost of replacing the stock top triple if you decide to go with clipons (you could continue to use the stock triple, but with no bars mounted atop, it'd look a little naff IMO). Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: Privateer on August 29, 2013, 10:17:53 PM the SM bars aren't that much lower, from my experience, altho they're rotated down more which made my wrists happy
before: (https://sphotos-a.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-prn1/34130_1506855476566_1777957_n.jpg) after: (https://sphotos-a.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-prn1/34130_1506855516567_5491452_n.jpg) Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: stopintime on August 30, 2013, 12:30:40 AM Clip ons typically have a 7 degrees down angle.
Suburban doesn't. Stock sweep is 18 degrees. Suburban is 24, typical clip ons at ~30. Clip ons will feel about the same as your 1198, but higher, depending on your choise of risers. Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: ungeheuer on August 30, 2013, 01:40:50 AM Clip ons will feel about the same as your 1198, but higher, depending on your choise of risers. I feel as though I'm pushing thru corners with much better precision with clipons than with regular handlebars.... don't really understand how that is actually possible ... other than placing my weight/input more forward, a little lower.... but that is certainly how it feels.Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: suzyj on August 30, 2013, 01:43:15 AM I obsessed over just the same option when I swapped my forks for 998 ones. I ended up going with zero-rise woodcraft clip-ons above the triple. It's a really comfy position. Aggressive without being nuts. Heaps of angle and very narrow.
(https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-1TJ6s7id9iw/UZInerldN6I/AAAAAAAACkc/NwncnKlULs8/w1644-h1092-no/DSC_3499.JPG) If you're patient, you can even cut the bar mounts off your existing triple so it doesn't look sucky. (https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-EdQzZAVD8JY/T0c4mFIFqVI/AAAAAAAABCg/LMLfrmjUOrw/s1223/DSC_2852.JPG) Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: Raux on August 30, 2013, 03:13:43 AM I have a 696 and run woodcraft zero rise under the triple with the 1" wider bars they have
In this pic you can see my setup, a typical Monster and a 1198. (http://sphotos-a-dfw.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ash2/530861_473811676008899_1578206640_n.jpg) Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: ungeheuer on August 30, 2013, 03:30:49 AM If you're patient, you can even cut the bar mounts off your existing triple so it doesn't look sucky. Nice job [thumbsup] [thumbsup](https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-EdQzZAVD8JY/T0c4mFIFqVI/AAAAAAAABCg/LMLfrmjUOrw/s1223/DSC_2852.JPG) Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: DarkMonster620 on August 30, 2013, 04:57:29 AM I obsessed over just the same option when I swapped my forks for 998 ones. I ended up going with zero-rise woodcraft clip-ons above the triple. It's a really comfy position. Aggressive without being nuts. Heaps of angle and very narrow. <snip> If you're patient, you can even cut the bar mounts off your existing triple so it doesn't look sucky. (https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-EdQzZAVD8JY/T0c4mFIFqVI/AAAAAAAABCg/LMLfrmjUOrw/s1223/DSC_2852.JPG) suzyj, did you bore out the top triple or replace it with a 998 one? I understand you cut the supports for the steering bar, but, the 998 are wider or am I still a bit sleepy? btw, I have that same configuration, Woodcraft 0 rise on top of the top triple . . . Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: suzyj on August 30, 2013, 05:04:29 AM suzyj, did you bore out the top triple or replace it with a 998 one? I understand you cut the supports for the steering bar, but, the 998 are wider or am I still a bit sleepy? btw, I have that same configuration, Woodcraft 0 rise on top of the top triple . . . It's the stock 695 triple, bored out. The 998 triple is quite different. Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: DarkMonster620 on August 30, 2013, 05:06:45 AM It's the stock 695 triple, bored out. The 998 triple is quite different. Thanks !!! Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: NAKID on August 30, 2013, 07:34:31 AM I obsessed over just the same option when I swapped my forks for 998 ones. I ended up going with zero-rise woodcraft clip-ons above the triple. It's a really comfy position. Aggressive without being nuts. Heaps of angle and very narrow. (https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-1TJ6s7id9iw/UZInerldN6I/AAAAAAAACkc/NwncnKlULs8/w1644-h1092-no/DSC_3499.JPG) If you're patient, you can even cut the bar mounts off your existing triple so it doesn't look sucky. (https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-EdQzZAVD8JY/T0c4mFIFqVI/AAAAAAAABCg/LMLfrmjUOrw/s1223/DSC_2852.JPG) Very similar to my setup. Very streetable. I'm 5'9" and I can comfortably sit up with both hands on the bars. Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: asherrick on August 31, 2013, 11:38:18 AM Thanks for all of the feedback, guys (and gal)! My goal is to get more weight over the front weight and a little better high-speed stability. Again, I don't want to turn this into a Superbike, so I'm looking for that middle ground.
Privateer, thanks for the before-and-after pictures of your SM bars! Do you happen to have a picture from the top of the bike showing the bar position in the clamp? I'm curious to see how you have it oriented. With the M1100s the clipons would need to be mounted below the triple. It would seem like a zero-rise setup would be too low, and much lower than the SM bars. Am I right? Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: Raux on August 31, 2013, 11:54:47 AM Yes
Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: SpikeC on August 31, 2013, 12:46:26 PM Wen I mounted the SM bars on my 1100S I needed to rotate then down a bit to work right for me and that put their hole for the left side switch cluster in the wrong place. I had to cut off the peg and add a bit of black tape to secure the cluster.
I liked the position quite a bit, it was close to my BMW R1100S. Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: asherrick on August 31, 2013, 01:04:58 PM From searching around the forum it seems like most people that have gone to clipons have done a 3" rise. Any idea how this compares to SM bars? Compared to stock (I actually have a Rizoma bar, so the taper is different)?
Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: stopintime on August 31, 2013, 01:14:57 PM If you get clip ons with replaceable risers (Woodcraft) you can buy other heights to adjust later on OR buy 3" and slide them down on the fork tubes IF you want to lower them.
Comparing to Rizoma will depend on which Rizoma model you have, but the usual Rizoma bars have about the same sweep angle as Suburban - quite a bit higher than stock though (~2") Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: Raux on August 31, 2013, 08:55:35 PM On the new monsters the tanks dictate the rises
zero come below the tank to the frame 3“ hit the stock air intake indents anywhere inbetween limits yout turn radius Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: SpikeC on September 01, 2013, 09:10:59 AM I did have to adjust the fork stops on my 09 1100.
Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: ute on September 01, 2013, 03:28:28 PM I have the SM bars ..love um , just rotate down to find your "sweet spot" but as said above you must delete the locate pegs in your switch gear ..no biggie
now that being said I have not used clips on my Monster just on the Gixxer , but like you said you want a middle ground not a Superbike I say go with SM if you don't like you can always sell on here Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: asherrick on September 01, 2013, 05:09:31 PM I just realized that I completely forgot something...my DP steering damper that attaches to the handlebar mount. I'll need to lose that if I go with clipons. Hmm...I'm thinking that I may start with the SM bars and see where that gets me.
Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: seanster on September 03, 2013, 06:19:03 AM I like these Apex clipons. Just rotabe the bars and it will give you different angle, plus there is raise options of 3 or 4"
http://www.apexmfg.com/products (http://www.apexmfg.com/products) Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: Stormtrooper on September 04, 2013, 08:50:25 AM I run Woodcraft 2.5" rise on my 796 - I would recommend them. The forward riding position made handling and turn-in more precise without adding too much weight on the wrists...a good compromise IMO. With new adapters you can go from zero rise to 3" rise without changing the entire setup.
These pics may help you: Stock bars vs Woodcraft 2.5" (a 5" drop in grip location + more natural angle) (http://i113.photobucket.com/albums/n206/jmlenz/IMG_20121005_134330.jpg) (http://s113.photobucket.com/user/jmlenz/media/IMG_20121005_134330.jpg.html) Stock flipped bars vs Woodcraft 2.5" (a 2.5" drop in grip location) (http://i113.photobucket.com/albums/n206/jmlenz/IMG_20121005_134535.jpg) (http://s113.photobucket.com/user/jmlenz/media/IMG_20121005_134535.jpg.html) Fully installed: (http://i113.photobucket.com/albums/n206/jmlenz/DSC03630_zpscd788653.jpg) (http://s113.photobucket.com/user/jmlenz/media/DSC03630_zpscd788653.jpg.html) (http://i113.photobucket.com/albums/n206/jmlenz/DSC03640_zpsee0b18be.jpg) (http://s113.photobucket.com/user/jmlenz/media/DSC03640_zpsee0b18be.jpg.html) Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: asherrick on September 04, 2013, 09:53:35 AM Fantastic photos, Stormtrooper! That really illustrates the height difference.
Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: ungeheuer on September 04, 2013, 04:33:58 PM I run Woodcraft 2.5" rise on my 796 - I would recommend them. The forward riding position made handling and turn-in more precise without adding too much weight on the wrists...a good compromise IMO. +1. Whilst I'm running 3.5" Swatts (and previoiusly 2.5") my experience echos 'trooper's.Fantastic photos, Stormtrooper! That really illustrates the height difference. Yup, a perfect visualisation, good work Stormtrooper [thumbsup] [clap] Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: Rudemouthsky on September 05, 2013, 06:21:13 AM Get the Suburban bars because they're made in CLEVELAND, baby.
Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: asherrick on September 17, 2013, 06:03:23 PM Thanks for your help, everyone! I selected the Suburban Machinery bars. So far I like them but I have a few issues to sort out. The first one is that the stock mirrors are now completely worthless. Is my only option a bar end mirror? I generally don't care for the looks of them.
Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: teddy037.3 on September 17, 2013, 07:19:59 PM Thanks for your help, everyone! I selected the Suburban Machinery bars. So far I like them but I have a few issues to sort out. The first one is that the stock mirrors are now completely worthless. Is my only option a bar end mirror? I generally don't care for the looks of them. you could try aftermarket stalk mounted mirrors; there's all sorts of height/angle to them, you may find one that'll work with the lower bar position. or is the problem due to rotation of the controls? :edit: I ran 1st gen SM bars on my 620... re-drilled the holes for the controls to better suit how I wanted the bars angled. FWIW, I loved them; perfect for my height/reach vs. the stock bar Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: Steve.In.Atlanta on September 17, 2013, 07:27:18 PM Thanks for your help, everyone! I selected the Suburban Machinery bars. So far I like them but I have a few issues to sort out. The first one is that the stock mirrors are now completely worthless. Is my only option a bar end mirror? I generally don't care for the looks of them. What I've liked the most about bar end mirrors is the convex mirror let's me pretty much see behind me which is good on the road to make sure my ass isn't being ridden. Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: asherrick on September 18, 2013, 07:56:08 PM you could try aftermarket stalk mounted mirrors; there's all sorts of height/angle to them, you may find one that'll work with the lower bar position. I'm not sure that stalk mirrors will be tall/high enough with the lower bars. That's the problem that I'm having with the stock mirrors. Title: Re: More aggressive ergos: clip-one vs. Suburban Machinery bars Post by: teddy037.3 on September 18, 2013, 10:34:57 PM I'm not sure that stalk mirrors will be tall/high enough with the lower bars. That's the problem that I'm having with the stock mirrors. then maybe it's time to jump on the bar-end train :) they're not all ugly... I felt the same way, but they actually work quite well to see behind you, and some look downright nice on the monster. (http://i.imgur.com/Nc7nMGa.jpg) |