1100EVO Does it really have 100 hp?

Started by koko64, June 26, 2011, 03:39:04 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

He Man

Quote from: ungeheuer on June 27, 2011, 04:51:00 AM
You answered your own question.  Crank HP is fictional coz in reality its not what you get.  As you've identified, losses can be many and varied.  Motorcycle (and other vehicle) manufacturers like to quote crank numbers.... coz they're more impressive, but they're fairly meaningless when attempting to compare one bike's stats against another's.
^^ What koko64 said.



Well, for the sake of arguing... When you build a motor for a vehicle, do you test the ENGINE for proper HP output, or do you put the whole car together then dyno it to make sure the CAR is making the right power?

When you transplant a motor from one vehicle to another, do you use crank HP or do you use RWHP from a totally different car? I am using this reference because the same motor is used in many different cars but maintains the same HP rating, however the drive train is completely different. Think about the V8 ford uses in the Econoline and F150. Same motor different drive train.

And when you add non engine mods to the bike, you can only "Free up" hp. So if you bolted on a bunch of stuff, ligth weight wheels blah blah blah, you know you can never actually make your M1100EVO a 100hp bike  because its 100hp crank, which means thats the max output of the motor. The average car joe knows that rwhp has about 15-20% lost. so u just multiply and subtract. But going the other way around, u have to set up a mini equation which is annoying to do. 15% of what = my RWHP?

I know all this stuff is just mumble jumble cause in reality all you want to know is how much useable power your getting when your putting it down on the road. but i dont think crank HP is a fictional bs number at all. it would be great if they advertise both.


And for the record my 1000DS puts 82rwhp. ;)

Goat_Herder

Anyhooooo.  1100EVO engine is rated at 100 hp.  That's the story and I am sticking to it. 
Goat Herder (Tony)
2003 Ducati Monster 620 - Yellow SOLD
2007 Ducati Monster S2R1000 - Black KILLED
2007 Ducati Monster S2R1000 - Red

koko64

My modified M900 makes 81 STD rwhp or 80 SAE rwhp corrected on the same dyno. It stomps on a freezing cold day with low humidity (and measured with uncorrected hp) [evil].

I know of a dyno that will give me nearly 90 [laugh].

Hey He Man if I go to that dyno my bike will blow yours out of the water! (As long as you don't take your bike there too) ;).


2015 Scrambler 800

Raux

i look at it this way..

if Ducati rates all its motors the same way then it has more than any previous 2v ducati motor.

koko64

#19
Thats true Raux.
Compared to my old girl,
more capacity, better ports, bigger valves, more efficient combustion chambers, better cams, more compression, better fuel delivery, better ignition.
Its just evolution.
2015 Scrambler 800

Kopfjager

Quote from: Raux on June 29, 2011, 03:54:01 AM
i look at it this way..

if Ducati rates all its motors the same way then it has more than any previous 2v ducati motor.

They didn't used too, but fell victim. If you want to know real numbers, put it on the Dyno.
Woohoohoohoo! Two personal records! For breath holding and number of sharks shot in the face.

bikepilot

Its totally true that dyno operators can fudge the numbers.  I once witnessed a dyno operator at a dyno day stress a bit when he saw that a bike he "built" for a customer (to the tune of $6k for the engine work) got beat out by an older, stock bike.  His sollution was to fiddle with the dyno and run the customer's "built" bike an extra six times until it finally spit out a winning number  [roll]
2009 XB12XT
2006 Monster 620 (wife's)
1997 TL1000S
1975 Kawasaki H1 Mach III
2001 CR250R (CO do-it-all bike)
2000 XR650R (dez racer)
2003 KX100 (wife's)
1994 DR250SE (wife's/my city commuter)

WhiteStripe

I have spent a couple decades on car forums.  For purposes of the internet, the most relevant measurement is the butt dyno.

The formula to get to HP is easy. 
- Take stock HP as quoted by manufacturer, wheel or crank doesn't matter. 
- Add 10% because your vehicle is special. 
- Add 20% for drivetrain loss (whether you started at wheel or crank is irrelevant)
- take a +5% bonus for any stickers from tuners or local street racing clubs.
- add 50hp on top of that if you "smoked" some guy in a Porsche GT2 the other day

then....put that you are putting down 500HP in your signature and join the argument about Mustang vs. Dynojet.

My S2R 1000 is easily putting down a 100+ HP at the wheel, i destroyed a guy on a Yamaha R1 this morning on the way to work.
2006 S2R 1000, Arrow CF exhaust, FatDuc 02, CF open cc with stock pp

koko64

Quote from: WhiteStripe on June 29, 2011, 07:13:06 AM
I have spent a couple decades on car forums.  For purposes of the internet, the most relevant measurement is the butt dyno.

The formula to get to HP is easy. 
- Take stock HP as quoted by manufacturer, wheel or crank doesn't matter. 
- Add 10% because your vehicle is special. 
- Add 20% for drivetrain loss (whether you started at wheel or crank is irrelevant)
- take a +5% bonus for any stickers from tuners or local street racing clubs.
- add 50hp on top of that if you "smoked" some guy in a Porsche GT2 the other day

then....put that you are putting down 500HP in your signature and join the argument about Mustang vs. Dynojet.

My S2R 1000 is easily putting down a 100+ HP at the wheel, i destroyed a guy on a Yamaha R1 this morning on the way to work.


[clap]  [laugh] [clap]
2015 Scrambler 800

He Man


Autostrada Pilot

Quote from: He Man on June 30, 2011, 03:47:45 PM
in that case i fixed my signature.

That's the funniest thing I've ever read, today.
2003 Monster 620 Dark - Sold

1999 Monster 900 City - Sold

After 7 years of Monsters, I'm sadly bikeless right now.

koko64

The best part was "pregnant doges", I just keep thinking of "Talladega Nights". [clap]
2015 Scrambler 800