We had great weather today so I decided to ride up to the dealership to get the bike checked out. Upon inspection they found that one of the plugs on the O2 sensor was missing. Therefore one O2 sensor was getting vastly different readings than the other one, and tripping the CEL as a result. They said that it probably wasn't screwed on tight enough from the factory and that it wiggled it's way out during my first ride. Simple problem... all fixed.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2383b/2383b2f2ca69b1f99e08d3c41f3e562bf920b1da" alt="Smiley"
Now let's just hope that the beautiful weather sticks around. (it got up to 54 today!!!)