There are at least two iterations of DP fairings for the old Monster (pre 2000).
My first Monster had that version purchased from the DP catalogue, but my current bike has the rounder more curved version used on the 98-99 M900 S and some '97-'99 bikes. Both DP ones are carbon.
I think your version can clear the clip on bars easier. They were worth a fortune in 1996!
The S4R fairing will be a good compromise, and the stripe is fine.
TOO FUNNY!! I just spoke with a friend and he has the DP 98'-99 in Carbon Fiber offering to sell to me.
But I would have to custom fit it & possibly cut it down in areas to make it work with my DP gauges & Cycle Cat triple clamp, no longer as attachment points for the brackets.