Thanks He Man and Speeddog for the recommendations
I talked to my vendor and Penske before trying anything since it was a brand new shock and didn't want to break anything. I noticed the blue fitting had a few more threads on it and what do you know... that worked!
My main concern was snapping the fitting but they said the worse thing that can happen is it snaps and you have to send it back to us
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d6b61/d6b618cf7bcb59284864305a580a47e30396d212" alt="waytogo"
to Pete @ GMDComputrak in Boston and Mike @ PRS for being very quick, helpful and supportive with resolving this!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f29cf/f29cfef97ab988d8c8bf99ca8727345271b15d77" alt=""