What would your next bike be?
I have been contemplating this for a while ... not because I am looking, but because you asked - and it is far too complicated a question.
Firstly I would have to state that the Boss has been quite clear that only certain marques will be allowed in the shed so that is quite limiting (down to one brand basically). The Tiger seems alright - I have tried to convince the Boss' bro to test one but he could never be convinced to buy something so modern.
Then it becomes a question of addition or replacement.
The addition that would be most likely to gain admittance to the shed would be a Ducati Cruiser (or maybe a Brio ... which would be seriously out-performed by the Lammy). Maybe another Lammy would make the cut - if it was the right bike. I don't mind the look of the 946 but they seem bloody expensive (and would be an anti-Lammy no-no). Depending on circumstances something like the Aprilia SRV 850 could be the go as a practical proposition (still an Italian, still a 90deg V-twin apparently).
Beyond that the Hyperstrada could be interesting to fill a certain niche ... but it would be exactly that and therefore seems rather silly.
Replacement would only be a 'heaven forbid' type scenario at which point there would be more important decisions to be made. The Diavel would probably be out because it seems to attract the wrong type of attention, locks you into position and looks stupid when you 'hang-off' plus it is in a higher CTP bracket. The Streetfighter would probably be the pick due to egonomics ... and although I have never ridden an 848 that would probably be more than enough for my modest abilities.
Certainly the new Monster would have to be looked at ... but as yet I have not been able to. The old new-gen Monster doesn't inspire me so I would need to at least see the M1200 in the metal to even consider it.
So there you go ... that didn't answer your question at all, did it?