So I am playing this Poker Game tonight...

[ROBsS4R]

And this hand shows up on a ALL IN Pot 



There is about $200 in the pot. What would you guys do?

[ducati_tim]

I'd pull out my derringer and shoot that cheatin' bastid in his ten gallon hat 

[55Spy]

if it's a friendly game with friends

miss deal,

pull back everything that each of you put in and split pot if the pot sucked in more than just the two of you and move on with life

if it's not a friendly game then kill the other guy and take all the money

[slowpoke13]

shoot first. Don't bother with questions.

[ROBsS4R]

I stabbed him with a Butter Knife 

[eltristo]

Aces n' Eights... dead man's hand.  Yer SOL, brotha. 

[Popeye the Sailor]

And this hand shows up on a ALL IN Pot 



There is about $200 in the pot. What would you guys do?

If I had the 8, I'd argue that because we all had the same chance with the fubar deck, I was still the winner.

[ROBsS4R]

It was a Flush Hand.

In any case it was a group of old friends. About 10 of us who throw $20 in the pot and play ever few weeks.

We got a good laugh over it. Apparently someone was playing a 2 deck card game with the exact same style of deck.

The Deck was totally Fudged up to. It had 52 cards but it had many duplicates.

[slowpoke13]

how many rounds did it take to notice?

[ROBsS4R]

We played for about 2 hours with 1 good deck and 1 Bad deck before we noticed 

[slowpoke13]

umm yeah... someone should have gotten shanked...

[derby]

If I had the 8, I'd argue that because we all had the same chance with the fubar deck, I was still the winner.

if aces or a flush hit the table, A8 has an advantage. they both have equal shots at a full house.

[KnightofNi]

quit playing pinochle and you won't have that problem 

[El Matador]

The last time I saw something like that come up in a money game, both guys got the shit kicked outta them. And these were friends we were playing with...

[Johnny OrganDonor]

Should'a kept playing to see if you could draw into a full house flush.