1100 Evo Vs 1100 DS.

Started by koko64, September 21, 2015, 03:29:16 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

koko64

Asking the knowledgable here.
What are the differences? Including MTS and HM models as well as the Monsters. I understand the 1100 MTS only came as DS models, but were wet clutch.
Cheers.
2015 Scrambler 800

Raux

Mts and hm are narrow cases

koko64

All 1100 Hypers are dry clutch, whether Evo or DS, so the only dry clutch Evo motor is in the Hyper1100Evo.
2015 Scrambler 800

caperix

I know the intake ports are bigger on the evo engine. I have heard the cams are the 1100 ds dp spec but do not know 100% on that

He Man

asaik ( which isnt much)

the 1100DS motor is dry clutch in most cases, and is nothing more than a 1000 motor with bigger piston.

the 1100EVO motor is single spark, is only dry clutch in the HM, otherwise wet clutch, has lighter flywheel and timing gear. the timing sensor is also located at a diff location and is a different size as well. the cases are also made using a new vaccum method that makes it lighter and thinner( there is a significant weight savings on the EVO motor cases compared to the 1100).

It also has a different cam profile then the 1100DS does.

it also has composite material valve covers instead of aluminum.


EEL

Quote from: He Man on September 21, 2015, 09:43:54 AM
asaik ( which isnt much)


LOL, "isn't much" .  Says the guy who fit an 1100evo motor in an s2r.

You probably know an order of magnitude more than the service personnel at my local dealership.

He Man

im just a wrench monkey slapping shit together lol
i dont know shit.

I don't think i ever told the whole story of how i came about that motor, but basically, i bought it off a drunk on the street without knowing if it was going to fit for not. He was heavily heavily drunk. The thing was sitting inside his jetski which was in a small ass garage at his mothers place in brooklyn. I paid a song for it and it wasnt even ready for its 600 mile service, ended up fitting pretty nicely.


koko64

Quote from: caperix on September 21, 2015, 08:49:26 AM
I know the intake ports are bigger on the evo engine. I have heard the cams are the 1100 ds dp spec but do not know 100% on that

According to the bikeboy cam chart, Evo cams have more lift and duration than the DS cams. The DP cams appear similar but a little different.

2015 Scrambler 800

koko64

Quote from: He Man on September 21, 2015, 01:18:48 PM
im just a wrench monkey slapping shit together lol
i dont know shit.

I don't think i ever told the whole story of how i came about that motor, but basically, i bought it off a drunk on the street without knowing if it was going to fit for not. He was heavily heavily drunk. The thing was sitting inside his jetski which was in a small ass garage at his mothers place in brooklyn. I paid a song for it and it wasnt even ready for its 600 mile service, ended up fitting pretty nicely.



Pretty tough jetski motor. [evil]
2015 Scrambler 800

ungeheuer

1100 Evo has just two spark plugs.

Whereas 1100 Dual Spark does not.

Weird .

;)
Ducati 1100S Monster Ducati 1260S Multistrada + Moto Guzzi Griso 1200SE


Previously: Ducati1200SMultistradaDucatiMonster696DucatiSD900MotoMorini31/2

koko64

#10
 ;D

I think the DS with its heavier flywheel and innards will be smoother and easier to roll along at lower speeds is my guess. The light internals of the Evo, based on my riding experience of my Hyper (assuming the internals are lightened like the Evo M1100), are almost too much of a good thing. You can feel how instantly it spins up with corresponding engine braking. Certainly potentially very on/off riding requiring good throttle control at lower speeds. Great when going for it, but not so good in slow traffic. It leaves a narrow tuning margin for 1/4 and less throttle.
2015 Scrambler 800

ungeheuer

.... you ride my DS Monster...

I'll ride your Evo Hyper...

and then we'll both know  [thumbsup]



Or at least have an informed opinion.



all care, no responsibility
Ducati 1100S Monster Ducati 1260S Multistrada + Moto Guzzi Griso 1200SE


Previously: Ducati1200SMultistradaDucatiMonster696DucatiSD900MotoMorini31/2

ungeheuer

Quote from: Raux on September 21, 2015, 04:15:58 AM
Mts and hm are narrow cases
Sooo...

HM1100 engine is not the same as M1100 engine?

DS or Evo ??
Ducati 1100S Monster Ducati 1260S Multistrada + Moto Guzzi Griso 1200SE


Previously: Ducati1200SMultistradaDucatiMonster696DucatiSD900MotoMorini31/2

koko64

Good plan. We can conduct a vigorous testing regime.

The rear section of the cases comes between frame supports for a sturdy structure iirc according to Speeddog and Duckstew posts about frame and motor compatibilty. They know the details.
The swingarm pivot is encapsulated within the frame structure so the cases at the pivot are narrow enough to fit. It must give extra strength like the SBKs which is also useful for multi stradas. ;D
2015 Scrambler 800

He Man

Quote from: koko64 on September 22, 2015, 05:46:06 AM
;D

I think the DS with its heavier flywheel and innards will be smoother and easier to roll along at lower speeds is my guess. The light internals of the Evo, based on my riding experience of my Hyper (assuming the internals are lightened like the Evo M1100), are almost too much of a good thing. You can feel how instantly it spins up with corresponding engine braking. Certainly potentially very on/off riding requiring good throttle control at lower speeds. Great when going for it, but not so good in slow traffic. It leaves a narrow tuning margin for 1/4 and less throttle.

I totally concur. The EVO motor picks up like a BEAST. I mean that is trying to go into the future. Mine is fully tuned out and with a 14/51 gearing (-1 front and +1 rear) its still pretty twitchy low speed.

When I had my DR650, the rideability of the monster in urban traffic really evident and riding them back to back revealed how unpleasant of a ride the monster really is.

a heavier flywheel would soften the hit, but the DS1000 motor case covers is narrower, so i dont think the flywheel would swap over.

Its not the fastest bike out there, but it sure wants to get ridden like it is.